A well-loved stuffed elephant records a dramatic "documentary," convinced he is the target of a sinister plot. With a chaotic evidence board and wild accusations, he presents his case: pristine new stuffed animals have invaded, he barely survived a near-drowning in the sink, and worst of all, he was abandoned beneath the bed. As he relives his supposed betrayals, his paranoia grows and fuels his belief that he has been replaced. But just when all hope seems lost, a flashback reveals the truth—his owner still cherishes him, pulling him back into a warm embrace. Realizing he may have overreacted, he awkwardly revises his theory and considers the newcomers as potential allies. Still, he remains ever-watchful...because you can never be too careful.